Journal article

Transformation of jarosite and iron oxyhydroxides in acid sulfate paddy soils

Open AccessMinerals containing Fe are ubiquitous in soils. By providing an abundance of sites for the sorption and incorporation of major and trace elements, Fe minerals can govern the fate and behaviour of numerous pollutants and nutrients in soils. Furthermore, the reactivity of Fe in redox-dynamic soils produces a web of Fe mineral transformation processes with broad consequences for element cycling. The importance of Fe cycling is no exception in acid sulfate soils, although the high sulfur and low pH conditions produce unique Fe mineral transformation processes and compositions. In acid sulfate soils, jarosite, an Fe-K hydroxysulfate mineral, and ferrihydrite, a common short-range-ordered Fe oxyhydroxide mineral, play a central role in the pedological development of active and post-active acid sulfate soils. Soil pH and the dynamics of metals, such as aluminium, are key to understanding the toxicity of acid sulfate soils and can be directly influenced by jarosite and ferrihydrite transformation processes. Although the transformation of Fe minerals is a key component of biogeochemical processes in redox-active soils, the variables that control the rates and pathways of Fe mineral transformations in soil remain uncertain. The uncertainty arises from the difficulty of tracing molecular processes within a matrix of diverse soil components. Iron minerals are regularly characterised in soils, but the processes that explain the Fe mineral composition of soils cannot be easily resolved. An alternative approach is to perform simplified experiments, such as mixed mineral suspension experiments, under controlled laboratory conditions, to test the effect of individual variables. These systems often use synthetic minerals, although relatively pure jarosite may also be isolated from soils and tested in mixed suspension experiments. While useful to derive mechanistic understanding, the measured outcomes of mixed suspension experiments may not represent the rates and products of transformations that occur in soils. Therefore, the objective of this thesis was to gain new understanding of the stability and transformation of jarosite and ferrihydrite in acid sulfate soils by developing novel experimental techniques to follow the transformation of synthetic jarosite and ferrihydrite directly in soils. The central theme of the thesis is the comparison of jarosite and aluminium-substituted jarosite transformation in experimental media of increasing complexity. The experiments are performed under conditions that are relevant to rice paddy soils because of the importance of rice in global food production, and the unique management of rice paddies whereby regular flooding during the growing season produces distinct redox cycles. In Thailand, large areas of the Chao Phraya River delta are cultivated as rice paddies despite being acid sulfate soils, providing a suitable site to observe the effects of regular redox cycling on the biogeochemistry of Fe minerals in acid sulfate soils. The thesis begins with characterisation of synthetic and natural jarosite mineral composition and reactivity. Spectroscopic techniques (Raman spectroscopy, Mössbauer spectroscopy and Energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometry) and X-ray diffraction (XRD) were used to assess the element substitution of mineral samples from two jarosite-alunite synthetic solid solution series. The same characterisation techniques were then applied to a sample of jarosite from an acid sulfate soil in Thailand has a natural Al-for-Fe substitution. The mineral characterisation was followed by a transformation experiment in a mixed-suspension system, similar to experimental designs that have been previously used to study mineral transformation processes. The experiment followed the transformation of the natural jarosite sample from an acid sulfate soil in Thailand and three jarosite samples with variable amounts of Al substitution. The reaction solution mimicked the pH (circumneutral) and Fe(II) content (up to 1:1 ratio of Fe(II) in solution to Fe(III) in solids) of flooded acid sulfate soils. Furthermore, using a 57Fe tracer, the simultaneous transformation processes that explained the distribution of mineral products could be resolved from one another. The transformation experiment revealed the relative reactivity of the minerals in the presence of Fe(II), and created a baseline that could be used to compare traditional mixed-suspension experiments with transformations in complex media such as soil. To advance mineral transformation experiments towards studies in which transformation processes may be followed within a soil matrix, several novel techniques were developed. In a first step, ferrihydrite was incubated for up to twelve weeks in microcosms, each containing 300 g of 5 mM CaCl2 solution and 250 g of one of five paddy soils. The ferrihydrite was buried in the soil within a mesh bag (polyethel terephthalate, 51 μm pores, 30 mm x 12 mm x 3 mm) that allowed free contact between the synthetic minerals and the pore water, but separated the minerals from direct contact with the soil matrix. The mineral products of the transformation were identified and quantified by Rietveld fitting of XRD patterns. Further, the spatial arrangements of the ferrihydrite and transformation products were measured after two weeks by Raman spectroscopy, which could be used to assess the effects of pore water chemistry and diffusion processes on mineral transformation in the mesh bags. The second step involved measuring jarosite and Al-substituted jarosite transformation in flooded topsoil and subsoils from a rice paddy located on the Bangkok Plain in Central Thailand using an adaptation of the mesh bag method. To test the effect of pore water on the transformation of jarosite in soil, mesh bags were filled with synthetic jarosite and aluminium-jarosite and incubated in topsoils and subsoils, both in laboratory mesocosms and directly in the field. Then, the effect of the soil matrix was tested by completing a parallel experiment using mesh bags containing soil that was pre-enriched with synthetic 57Fe-labelled jarosite and aluminium-substituted jarosite. To facilitate the deployment and collection of small mesh bags in large soil volumes, the mesh bags were inserted into soils using custom-designed 3D-printed sample holders. At three timepoints within twelve weeks, one set of mesh bags were removed from the soil. Transformation products were identified and quantified in the pure jarosite and aluminium-jarosite mesh bags using Rietveld fitting of XRD patterns, while the fate of the 57Fe in enriched soil mesh bags was traced using 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy. Performing experiments in increasingly complex media provides an insight into the effect of experimental design on the observation of Fe mineral transformations and provides new information regarding the transformation rates and pathways of jarosite and ferrihydrite within full complexity of soil media. Indeed, this thesis demonstrates that the complex chemistry, biological activity, and physical arrangement of components in the soil have strong effects on the rate and products of jarosite and ferrihydrite transformation processes. The transformation of jarosite and Al-substituted jarosite in mixed-suspension experiments presented in this thesis, in agreement with previous mixed-suspension experiments on both jarosite and ferrihydrite, occurred within a matter of hours. By contrast, the rate of ferrihydrite, jarosite and Al-jarosite transformation in soil pore and in direct contact with the soil matrix occurred over the course of several weeks or months. In the ferrihydrite mesh bags, slow ferrihydrite transformation kinetics on the outer rim of the mesh bag, and deep in the core of the mesh bag, indicated that the sorption of chemical components of soil pore water and diffusion limitations of Fe(II) in pore water could be reasons for the slower rates of transformation in soil. In addition, both Al-for-Fe substitution and Fe(II) concentration in solution were important factors that altered the rate of mineral transformation. The different incubation conditions for jarosite and Al-jarosite also altered the products of the transformation. Whereas the hydrolysis of jarosite in the absence of Fe(II) resulted primarily in the formation of ferrihydrite, jarosite transformation in the presence of Fe(II) led to ferrihydrite, goethite and lepidocrocite formation. The Fe oxyhydroxide products were consistent with Fe(II)-catalysed transformation, and Fe(II)-catalysed recrystallisation of jarosite may have occurred concurrently. Aluminium-for-iron substitution hindered the formation of lepidocrocite formation in favour of ferrihydrite and goethite. Similar product phases occurred when jarosite and Al-jarosite were reacted with pore water from acid sulfate soils, indicating that similar transformation pathways may define the mineral products of jarosite transformations when the jarosite occurs as accumulations of pure mineral in soil. However, non- or poorly crystalline phases predominated in the transformation products when jarosite or Al-jarosite were incubated in direct contact with the soil matrix, indicating that the transformation of jarosite under these circumstances was governed by different pathways and processes. The new insights into the transformation of ferrihydrite, jarosite and Al-jarosite in acid sulfate soils demonstrate that phases previously considered meta-stable may participate in the biogeochemistry of soil over period of several months. In the context of rice cultivation, the transformation processes may affect the biogeochemistry of the soils throughout the growing season. The formation of poorly crystalline minerals following the transformation in flooded soils may have positive consequences on the sequestration of other trace and major elements that were associated with the ferrihydrite, jarosite or Al-jarosite prior to the transformation. However, the stabilisation of reduced Fe in the soil matrix may have the opposite effect, promoting the mobility of other ions in solution. The methods used to incubate jarosite and ferrihydrite in soils are easily adaptable to new experimental questions involving the behaviour of Fe-bearing minerals in soil. Therefore, the findings open up a new class of experiments within environmental mineralogy and biogeochemistry, that can help to uncover the processes that occur in the environment and explain the natural variation in the composition of Fe phases in soil.

Contacts

Grigg, Andrew R.C.
Role: creator

Temporal

Updated: 2026-10-06T16:19:53Z
Temporal extent: date

License: Unknown

Language: Unknown
Updated: 2026-10-06